How to Pick Exterior Paint Colors

Get a Free Quote
How to Pick Exterior Paint Colors

Picking an exterior paint color for your house can feel overwhelming. The options seem endless and it’s hard to narrow down on a color scheme when you don’t know what you should be looking for. The interior of your home is where you can flex your personality and use your personal color preference while the exterior paint should be more about durability. You want paint that will last!

As you consider paint colors for your home’s exterior, stick with what you know and love! This is your largest investment and by choosing colors that look good and last longer you’re going to be doing more than just protecting your house, your increasing its value and stretching your dollar!

Step 1: Decide What Color Tone You Want

First things first, decide what color tone you want. Do you want something light and bright, mid-tone, or dark for the body of your house? This is the easy part as most of us have some sort of vision that leans light or dark.


Light tone exterior paint

Light Tones would include all your earthy colors like white, beige, brown, and tan. These colors absorb lese UV rays which means your house stays cooler and is less likely to fade as compared to organic colors like reds, blues, greens and yellow.


Mid tone exterior paint

Mid-tones are the ones in the middle of the spectrum and they are neither dark or light. These colors may appear muted or slightly dull but are easy on the eyes. They aren’t as flirty as pastels, overwhelming as bright colors or dramatic as dark ones. Examples would be blue gray, peach, sage, or hay yellow.

Dark exterior paint

Some Dark tones would include black, charcoal gray, navy, dark forest green and dark violet. Dark exteriors are perfect for homes surrounded by beautiful greenery. The contrasts in tones are a sure-fire way to make your house stand out. While these aren’t the most popular exterior color due to it’s inevitable fading, dark colors are sophisticated, elegant, modern and edgy. If a dark color scheme seems a bit much, consider just painting your front door a bold dark color.

Step 2: Choose Based on Underlying Colors and Environment

Look at your home and take note of it’s personality and its surroundings! Do you have interesting architecture features you want to highlight? Is there existing stone or brick that you are keeping? Do you have a lot of colorful plants and shrubbery? What about the color of your roof? Think about working with the underlying colors within that material and stay away from ones that will clash.

exterior house color underlying color tones

What are underlying colors exactly? We have three primary colors, red, yellow and blue. All other colors are combinations of those mixed together. Tone is related to the amount of black or white within the color. Let’s say you have a house with browish stone like the one pictured above. You can see that while the stone comes off as brown, it is compiled of a handful of colors like black, tan and cream. Those would be considered the materials underlying colors. Knowing that, you can then pull colors with the tone you are looking for to perfectly compliment your already existing material.

Some examples of colors that will clash with each other are: Red and purple. Brown and maroon. Brown and Black. Orange and Purple. Blue and Green. A good example of this would be, if you have a brown roof with green undertones you should stay away from painting your home blue!

Step 3: Check Color Schemes

At this point, if your home has underlying colors within existing material that you like and are drawn to, your decision should be pretty easy from here. If you have an HOA with pre-approved colors then simply look for a scheme that has the right tones you are looking for and then match the colors as closely as you can.

Don’t worry if you are still lost at this step. Do some research! Look at your HOA color schemes and browse Pinterest or Google for inspiration. Try searching phrases based off the style of your house like, “ranch style home exterior” or “Victorian home exterior.” You can also try searching terms like “light house exteriors” or “Dark  exterior houses.”


Color schemes

Check out our Pinterest board for inspiration or some of our custom color schemes above!

Step 4: Get Color Samples

You have finally narrowed down on a color scheme or two. Now it’s time to get samples! Expect that your color will look a tone lighter than what you see on the color chip. Paint tends to look lighter when exposed to natural light. When painting up your samples, do it in several areas around the house and look at them at different times during the day so you can see it’s true color.

If you have a stucco home, the paint may look a little darker because the texture creates shadows within the small indentations. If your home is made of both stucco and siding, consider painting them the same color. The texture and slight difference of tone will give your exterior depth.

With natural light also comes more color.  Once you paint those samples up you’re going to be able to see more of it’s underlying colors. Gray’s may look more purple or blue. Tan may seem a little more orange. Keep this in mind when picking colors and if you are worried about those colors coming through opt for a lighter tone within the same color family.


color samples


Color Samples

DO: Paint up samples once you have narrowed in on your final exterior colors

DONT: Waste your money and paint up a ton of different exterior color options

Try to wait until you’ve narrowed down your colors before you go painting up a bunch of different ones. Samples should be you narrowing in on a color, not painting up a dozen different ones to see what you like best. With sample cans running close to $10 a pop that ends up being a major waste of money.

If you are a visual person and you can’t help but want to see a bunch of colors on the home, try using Sherwin-Williams COLORSNAP Visualizer. This application lets you upload a photo of your home and see it painted as another color.

Step 5: Make your Decision

Stick with the colors and tones you know and love and if you ever need some advice, your friends here at Colorado Commercial & Residential Painting would be happy to assist you! Learn more with our guide on some of the best exterior paints for your home.

CHECK OUT SOME RECENT BEFORE AND AFTERS:


Exterior home painting


home painting


Exterior home painting


Exterior home


home painting


home painting

Share:

Trevor Z Marshall

Owner & Managing Member at Colorado Painting

Originally from Texas, I’m now thrilled to call Colorado home! Life at our house is full of energy, with four kids, a dog, a cat, and a rotating cast of fish (turns out they’re not the easiest pets to keep alive). Thankfully, my wife Erin and I somehow manage to stay afloat. I’m a proud graduate of Vanderbilt University and have been fortunate to live and work across the country, gaining valuable experiences along the way. When I’m not working, I enjoy making the most of Colorado’s beautiful outdoors, catching up with friends and family, following sports, especially European football, and exploring Boulder’s fantastic craft beer scene. I’m passionate about supporting our team members, whom we proudly refer to as Partners, in delivering top-tier customer service and achieving outstanding results. Looking forward to the opportunity to work together!

Danielle R.
1 day ago
If I could give Trevor and his team 10 stars I would. We were quoted by 3 companies and this company was honest, trustworthy, priced well and beyond professional. The attention to detail and commitment to making sure the job was done to our satisfaction, was evident every step of the way. We will definitely be repeat customers!
Fredrick B.
2 weeks ago
Colorado Painters did a great job with very clean and professional detailed look. They were very responsive to our timing needs, requirements and scheduling . Stephen, Ben, the paint teams and Jordan came together and provided a very nice paint job to finish out our sizable garage at a very very reasonable and effective price. Well Done, highly recommended!
Kenny
2 weeks ago
I had a great experience with this company. From getting a quote, to scheduling, to working with the crew they made the process easy. Also, the quality of the work and professionalism from the crew was top notch. Highly recommend this company.
Shelby C.
3 weeks ago
The team did an incredible job. The painting was done quickly, they protected our floors, cleaned up each day, and the final result looks amazing. I was kept informed on their progress every day and whole process was seamless. Highly recommend!
Joseph F.
3 weeks ago
I am absolutely thrilled with the exterior painting job recently completed on my home! From start to finish, the crew demonstrated unparalleled professionalism. They arrived on time every day, worked diligently, and treated my property with the utmost respect. Their attention to detail during the preparation phase was particularly impressive. They thoroughly power washed, scraped, and caulked every surface, ensuring a flawless foundation for the new paint. The final result is stunning—the colors are vibrant, the lines are crisp, and the finish is completely even. It has drastically transformed the curb appeal of my house. Furthermore, they maintained a clean workspace and did a fantastic job packing up all materials at the end of each day. Communication was seamless, and the project manager made sure I was 100% satisfied before considering the job done. I highly recommend their services to anyone looking for a high-quality, reliable, and beautiful exterior paint job!
Kari A.
3 weeks ago
Trevor and the team did a fantastic job painting the exterior of my house in Superior. The process was really easy, from paint selection to scheduling and the onsite work. I’d highly recommend them!
Kristin M.
1 month ago
Our crew for our job was outstanding! They were professional, efficient and attentive. Our house was a challenge with steep peaks and multiple finishes but they didn’t hesitate and the final product looks amazing.
Cindy R.
1 month ago
Colorado Painting staff were professional, friendly, timely and efficient in painting the exterior of my house. They cleaned up well after themselves. Very helpful as well.
Jeanne F.
1 month ago
We were extremely impressed with the entire experience with Colorado Painti! They communicated well with what was included, when they would be coming and were organized, efficient and the work crew was great. We could not have been more pleased!
Jessica W.
1 month ago
We are very happy with the work done by Colorado Commercial Painting. Crew showed up on time and the work was completed quickly and cleaned up perfectly.
Constance M.
1 month ago
Colorado Painting did an excellent job on our interior painting project. We had the majority of our home painted and we couldn't be more pleased with the outcome! Ben did an excellent job of checking in with me and the crew several times a day to see if we needed anything and to ensure things were running smoothly. Leo did a fantastic job managing his crew and making sure everyone was providing the best workmanship. They paid attention to every little detail and even did some amazing work on some drywall damage we needed to repair. The work was excellent quality!
Alyssa V.
1 month ago
The Erics we're all amazing with their help from the beginning to the end of our project. Their assistance with questions and concerns were quickly answered and taken care of professionally. Thank you for all of your hard work!
Jim T.
1 month ago
Did a great job.
Allison P.
1 month ago
Colorado Painting was great to work with. Their team was professional and fast. Their caulking and siding repair before painting stopped a leak we had around a sliding glass door. And the whole house paint job looks great! Also, our deck paint was peeling and the wood was chipping. They replaced a floor board in our deck and patched up holes and then painted and our deck looks brand new again!
Meghan G.
2 months ago
We couldn't be happier with our experience with Colorado Commercial & Residential Painting. From start to finish, the communication was outstanding. Ben, Joel, Joel Sr., and the entire crew were professional, responsive, and incredibly easy to work with throughout the project. What stood out most was their attention to detail and commitment to getting everything right. They took the time to address every question and concern, and they never made us feel rushed. The crew consistently showed up, followed through on their promises, and continued working with us until we were 100% satisfied with the final result. It's clear they take pride in their work and genuinely care about their customers. The finished product exceeded our expectations, and we would absolutely recommend Colorado Painting to anyone looking for a company that values quality, communication, and customer satisfaction.
janell44
2 months ago
I appreciated the great communication, from beginning to the end of the project. Good workmanship and attention to detail. I would highly recommend.
Constance M.
2 months ago
We had an amazing experience with Colorado Commercial & Residential Painting! We had a pretty big interior painting project with some drywall repair that we needed done. Ben, oversaw the project and did a great job checking in with me and the crew several times a day to see if things were going smoothly or if we needed anything. Leo led his painting crew and we couldn't be more pleased with his attention to detail! He did an excellent job with the drywall repairs, we can barely notice there was even a problem to begin with. He and his crew did a great job protecting our newly carpeted floors as well as all our furniture. Thanks for taking your time and doing such a great job! We will certainly call again for future projects!
Michael J.
2 months ago
Extremely satisfied with my experience! Eric, Jordan, Ben all kept in communication throughout the process phenomenally, and answered any questions i had as we went along in the process. Leo and his crew showed up daily at 8am. Did several siding, trim and soffit repairs that needed to be done and the prep work was detailed. The painting job itself i couldn’t be happier with. We love looking at our home and the excellent job the crew did to make sure it was done right. My property was left neat and clean each night that they left and trash was bagged and removed daily. Highly recommend this company. They went out of their way to make sure we were happy before taking payment. Would use again without hesitation!
Lori G.
2 months ago
Great company. Did a fantastic job and great communication the entire process.
Sarah W.
3 months ago
Leo & his team did a great job on our exterior. They were efficient & thorough, and offered their expertise when I had questions about a few areas. Highly recommend!
Home Advisor-top rated
best painters in westminster expertise badge
BBB Accredited Business
Rocky Mountain Chapter Community Associations Institute
PDCA Logo
lead safe paint
commercial painters